by 
Writing a book review is a wonderful way to share your thoughts and insights on a book you’ve read, helping others discover new reads or decide whether a particular book is for them.
Whether you’re an avid reader or just starting out, crafting a thoughtful and engaging review is a skill that anyone can develop.
In this post, I’ll walk you through 15 practical tips to consider when writing a book review, so you can confidently share your opinions while also giving the author helpful feedback.
Pin This For Later
1. Read the Book Thoroughly
It might sound obvious, but the first and most crucial step is to make sure you’ve read the book from cover to cover.
Skimming or skipping parts might lead to incomplete or unfair assessments.
A deep and thorough reading ensures that you grasp the full scope of the story, the character development, and the key themes.
This gives you the credibility to discuss the book honestly and in detail.
Tip: Take notes while you read. Jot down your initial reactions, quotes that resonate with you, or specific parts of the book that stand out. These will be useful when you start writing your review.
2. Identify the Book’s Genre and Audience
Before diving into your thoughts, identify the genre and intended audience of the book.
Understanding what type of book it is sets the stage for your review.
For instance, you wouldn’t judge a light-hearted romance by the same standards you’d apply to a literary thriller.
Recognizing the genre and audience also helps you stay objective.
Tip: Consider if the book succeeded within its genre. Did it entertain, inform, or provoke thought in a way that aligns with what readers expect from that genre?
3. Start with a Brief Synopsis
A good review often starts with a short synopsis of the book.
The key here is to give readers an idea of what the book is about without giving away spoilers.
Think of this as a quick overview that piques interest, rather than a full plot summary.
Keep it concise—just a few sentences are enough to set the stage.
Tip: When writing the synopsis, try to highlight the central conflict or theme of the book. This helps potential readers decide whether the subject matter interests them.
Also See: 15 Simple Ways To Get Back Into Reading Books (+ Tips To Get Started ASAP)
4. Share Your Overall Impression
Once you’ve introduced the book, it’s time to dive into your overall impression.
Did the book meet your expectations? Was it engaging, thought-provoking, or a struggle to get through?
Your overall thoughts set the tone for the rest of the review.
Be honest but balanced—whether you loved it or had some reservations, share your true feelings while considering different perspectives.
Tip: Instead of just saying, “I loved this book,” explain why. Did the characters resonate with you? Was the plot engaging? Offering specifics makes your review more informative.
5. Analyze the Characters
One of the most important aspects of a book is its characters.
Talk about how well the author developed them.
Were they relatable, complex, or flat? Did their actions make sense within the context of the story? If a character left a particular impression on you, good or bad, explain why.
Tip: Reflect on whether the characters evolved throughout the story. A dynamic character arc can make a book memorable, so discuss any growth (or lack thereof) that you observed.
6. Evaluate the Plot and Pacing
Next, consider the book’s plot.
Was it well-constructed? Did the story keep you engaged from beginning to end, or were there moments when your attention drifted?
Pacing is key to a successful book—too slow, and readers may get bored; too fast, and important details may be missed.
Your thoughts on how the author handled the plot and pacing are valuable insights for potential readers.
Tip: It’s helpful to point out any twists or surprising moments without giving them away. Did the book keep you guessing, or was it predictable? This can help readers gauge if the story aligns with their preferences.
You May Also Like: 22 Bookish Things to Do Over the Holidays (That Aren’t Just Reading)
7. Discuss the Writing Style
Every author has a unique voice, and part of reviewing a book is reflecting on the writing style.
Is the prose beautiful and lyrical, or more straightforward and concise? Did the language enhance the story, or did it feel too simplistic or overly flowery?
The way a story is written can greatly impact a reader’s experience, so it’s worth mentioning.
If the book’s writing style is particularly effective in certain parts (like descriptive scenes or dialogues), give examples. This helps readers understand the author’s strengths.
Pin This For Later
8. Reflect on the Themes
Books often explore certain themes, such as love, identity, grief, or justice.
Think about what themes were present in the book and how well they were explored.
Did the book make you think about these themes in new ways, or did it feel shallow?
Discussing themes is particularly important for more literary works, where the message or ideas might carry more weight than the plot.
Don’t be afraid to share personal reflections here. How did the themes resonate with you personally? Did the book challenge your views or reinforce them?
9. Mention Strengths and Weaknesses
A balanced review highlights both what worked and what didn’t work in the book.
Maybe the characters were vivid and well-developed, but the plot had some holes. Or perhaps the story was engaging, but the pacing felt off in parts.
Providing both strengths and weaknesses gives readers a more comprehensive picture.
When discussing weaknesses, try to be constructive rather than harsh.
Instead of saying, “The writing was bad,” you might say, “The writing style didn’t appeal to me because it felt too simplistic.”
10. Avoid Spoilers (or Warn Readers)
One of the most important rules in writing a book review is to avoid spoilers unless you clearly warn readers beforehand.
Spoiling major plot points can ruin the reading experience for others, so be mindful of how much you reveal.
If you need to discuss something that happens later in the book, consider adding a spoiler alert.
A good way to avoid spoilers is to focus on how the book made you feel or what it made you think, rather than giving a blow-by-blow account of what happened.
11. Consider the Ending
The ending of a book often leaves a lasting impression, and it’s worth reflecting on whether the conclusion satisfied you.
Did the ending tie up loose ends, or was it abrupt and unresolved?
If it’s part of a series, did it leave you eager for the next installment?
While avoiding spoilers, you can discuss how the ending affected your overall enjoyment of the book.
If the ending surprised you, mention whether it felt earned or out of place. A well-crafted twist can elevate a book, but a random twist might feel frustrating.
12. Rate the Book (If You Use a Rating System)
If you’re reviewing books on platforms like Goodreads or Amazon, you’ll likely need to assign a star rating.
This can be tricky since ratings are subjective, but try to base your rating on a combination of factors: writing quality, plot, characters, and personal enjoyment.
Explain your rating in the review to give context to your score.
If you’re conflicted about your rating, don’t be afraid to give a nuanced explanation.
For example, you could say, “I’m giving this 4 stars because while I loved the plot, I found the pacing slow in parts.”
Related: How To Read 100+ Books & Articles A Month: 20 Valuable Tips To Get You Started
13. Compare to Other Books (If Applicable)
Sometimes it’s helpful to compare the book you’re reviewing to others in the same genre or by the same author.
This can help readers who are familiar with similar works decide if the book is right for them.
For instance, if you’re reviewing a mystery novel, you might compare it to other books with similar twists or pacing styles.
Avoid making the comparison too negative. Instead of saying, “This book wasn’t as good as X,” you could say, “Fans of X may also enjoy this for its gripping plot and strong characters.”
14. Think About the Author’s Intentions
Consider what the author was trying to achieve with the book.
Was it a fun, light-hearted read meant to entertain, or a deeper, more serious novel exploring complex emotions or themes?
Evaluating the book based on the author’s intentions can help you stay fair in your critique.
For instance, if it’s meant to be a light summer read, it wouldn’t make sense to criticize it for not being deeply intellectual.
If you think the author successfully achieved what they set out to do, mention that.
You might say, “For a debut novel, this was a well-executed thriller that kept me on edge.”
15. Be Yourself!
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, be yourself when writing your review.
Don’t worry about sounding like a professional critic or using fancy language—what matters most is that your review reflects your genuine thoughts and feelings.
Readers appreciate honesty and authenticity, so let your personality shine through.
Don’t be afraid to inject a bit of humor or personal anecdotes into your review.
If a book reminded you of an experience you’ve had, share that! It makes your review more relatable and engaging.
Pin This For Later
Writing a book review is both a creative and thoughtful process.
By following these 15 tips, you’ll not only improve your reviews but also offer valuable insights to fellow readers and authors alike.
Remember, there’s no one “right” way to write a review—what’s most important is that you’re honest, thoughtful, and engaged with the material.
So, next time you finish a book, grab your pen (or keyboard) and start reviewing!
Your perspective is unique, and your voice matters in helping others find their next favorite read. Happy reviewing!
Read Next: How to Request ARCs from Publishers and Build Your Reading Stack
