by 
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this site. Your purchases help fund my content and come at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support!
I’ve been part of Reese’s Book Club for a couple of years now, and aside from absolutely loving the books she selects each month, I can say for a fact that the discussions are always incredibly insightful.
If you’ve been curious about the previous book club picks, I’ve created this post just for you!
Here, I’ve listed all the books selected for Reese’s Book Club, and of course, this post will be updated every month as she announces her latest pick.
I’ll also be sharing my reviews of all the books soon, so be sure to check back to see my thoughts—and whether I think each book is worth reading!
March 2025: Broken Country by Claire Leslie Hall
If you love stories packed with deep emotions, tangled pasts, and a touch of mystery, this one is for you.
Beth is happily married to Frank, but their peaceful life depends on keeping old secrets buried.
Everything changes when her brother-in-law fires a gun at a dog—because that dog belongs to Gabriel Wolfe, Beth’s first love and the man who broke her heart years ago.
Gabriel’s sudden return stirs up memories Beth thought she had put behind her, especially since his young son reminds her so much of the child she lost.
As old feelings resurface, so do long-hidden tensions in their small village, leading to dangerous consequences. Beth must decide whether to stay the woman she is now or embrace the one she used to be.
With the slow-burn intensity of The Paper Palace and the atmospheric pull of Where the Crawdads Sing, this book blends love, loss, and suspense into a gripping read you won’t be able to put down.
February 2025: Isola by Allegra Goodman
This sweeping historical novel feels like a classic adventure mixed with an unforgettable love story.
Marguerite was supposed to have a life of wealth and security—until she lost her parents and ended up in the care of a cruel guardian who wastes her fortune.
Forced to follow him on an expedition, she finds unexpected love with his servant, but their romance comes at a devastating cost.
When they’re discovered, they’re abandoned on a remote island, left to survive on their own.
Once a girl who wore pearls in her hair, Marguerite must now battle the elements, hunger, and loneliness.
As the island becomes her whole world, she discovers a strength and faith she never knew she had.
Based on a real-life 16th-century woman, Isola is a powerful story about resilience, survival, and love in the face of impossible odds.
January 2025: The Three Lives of Cate Kay by Kate Fagan
Imagine being a world-famous author—except no one knows who you really are. That’s Cate Kay’s reality.
She wrote a bestselling book series that became a Hollywood blockbuster, but she’s never done a single interview or public appearance. Because Cate Kay isn’t even her real name.
Years ago, she and her best friend Amanda dreamed of leaving their troubled lives behind and chasing stardom.
But the night before their big escape, tragedy struck, and Cate has been hiding ever since, changing her identity and rewriting her own story. Now, a shocking revelation forces her to stop running and finally return home to face the past.
If you loved The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo or First Lie Wins, this one has that same juicy, addictive pull—secrets, reinvention, and a woman finally telling her truth.
Winter 2024: Throwback by Maurene Goo
This one is so fun! It’s like Back to the Future meets The Joy Luck Club, with a heartwarming mother-daughter twist.
Sam Kang doesn’t understand her mom, Priscilla. They clash all the time—especially over Priscilla’s high school dreams of homecoming queens and perfect teenage years.
After a huge fight, Sam wishes she could just move on but instead, she time-travels back to the 1990s!
Now, she’s stuck in the past, attending high school with her teenage mom. The ‘90s are a whole different world—no smartphones, no social media, and some pretty outdated ideas.
But as Sam gets to know young Priscilla, she starts to see her in a new light. And when romance gets involved, things get even more complicated.
This book is packed with humor, nostalgia, and big questions about family, identity, and what we inherit from the generations before us.
December 2024: City of Night Birds by Juhea Kim
Set in the high-stakes world of Russian ballet, this novel is full of passion, heartbreak, and second chances.
Natalia Leonova was once the brightest star of her generation—until a devastating accident shattered her career.
Two years later, she returns to St. Petersburg, drowning in regret and pain. But the past won’t let her go.
There’s Alexander, the love of her life, who changed everything for her. And there’s Dmitri, a dark and brilliant dancer who offers her one last shot at redemption. But is stepping back into the world that nearly destroyed her worth the risk?
If you love books about ambition, art, and complicated love, this one is breathtaking.
It’s a haunting story about what it means to dedicate your life to something—and whether you can ever walk away.
November 2024: We Will Be Jaguars by Nemonte Nenquimo
This memoir is as powerful as it is inspiring. Nemonte Nenquimo grew up deep in the Amazon rainforest as part of the Waorani tribe, one of the last Indigenous groups to be contacted by outsiders.
As a child, she learned about plant medicine, storytelling, and the wisdom of the forest.
But when she was sent to study with missionaries in the city, she found herself caught between two worlds.
After years away, she felt the call to return home—and when the rainforest and her people came under threat from Big Oil, she stepped up to fight.
Nemonte became a leading voice in Indigenous activism, protecting over half a million acres of rainforest and reshaping the conversation around climate change.
Her story is raw, urgent, and deeply moving. If you’re looking for a memoir that will change the way you see the world, this is it.
October 2024: Society of Lies by Lauren Ling Brown
This dark academia thriller is full of secrets, privilege, and mystery. Maya has returned to Princeton for her college reunion, ready to celebrate her sister Naomi’s graduation.
But the weekend takes a horrifying turn—Naomi is found dead. The police say it was an accident, but Maya doesn’t believe them.
As she digs into Naomi’s last few months, she realizes her sister was involved in the same secret society Maya once belonged to.
And Naomi isn’t the first person from the society to die mysteriously. The deeper Maya searches, the more dangerous it becomes—because the secret she’s been keeping for years might be the key to everything.
With an elite college setting, hidden power plays, and a twisty mystery, this one is perfect if you love books like The Secret History or The It Girl.
Fall 2024: Looking for Smoke by K.A. Cobell
A murder mystery set on a Blackfeet reservation, this one is tense and unforgettable. When Mara is included in a traditional Giveaway ceremony to honor her friend Loren’s missing sister, she hopes it will help her feel more at home in the community.
But then, one of the girls from the ceremony—Samantha White Tail—is found dead.
Now, Mara and three others—Loren, Brody, and Eli—are the prime suspects. Each of them had history with Samantha, and each has something to hide.
If they want to clear their names, they’ll have to figure out the truth themselves. But what if the killer is one of them?
With rich cultural details and a suspenseful, locked-room mystery feel, Looking for Smoke is the kind of book you won’t be able to stop thinking about.
September 2024: The Comfort of Crows by Margaret Renkl
This book is like a quiet walk through the seasons, watching nature change and reflecting on life along the way.
Margaret Renkl takes us through a year in her backyard, sharing little moments with birds, plants, and the shifting weather.
There’s joy in the beauty of the natural world, but also sadness as she watches certain birds disappear and seasons change too quickly.
At the same time, her own life is shifting—kids growing up, the world moving forward, and the bittersweet mix of memories and hope.
With beautiful illustrations from her brother, this book is like a love letter to nature and a reminder to slow down and appreciate the small wonders around us.
If you love quiet, thoughtful books that make you feel connected to the world, this one is perfect.
August 2024: Slow Dance by Rainbow Rowell
Shiloh and Cary were the kind of friends everyone assumed would end up together. But life had other plans.
Shiloh left for college, Cary joined the Navy, and somehow, years passed without a word between them.
Now, at 33, Shiloh is back in her childhood home, a divorced mom of two, wondering what happened to all those dreams she once had.
When an old friend’s wedding brings them back into each other’s orbit, Shiloh isn’t sure what to expect. Will Cary even want to see her?
The answer is yes—so many yeses. This is a story about love that was there before either of them knew what love really was.
It’s about second chances, nostalgia, and the way people can drift apart, only to find their way back to each other.
If you love emotional, deeply romantic stories about finding love when you least expect it, this one’s a must-read.
July 2024: The Cliffs by J. Courtney Sullivan
A mysterious Victorian house on a cliff, an archivist returning home, and a history filled with secrets—this book has all the ingredients for an unforgettable read.
Jane has always been drawn to an abandoned house in Maine, a place full of forgotten stories. Now, years later, she’s back, hired to uncover its past.
But the new owner thinks the house is haunted, and as Jane digs into its history, she finds herself wrapped up in ghost stories, lost loves, and long-buried secrets.
This novel is rich with atmosphere, weaving together family drama, history, and a touch of the supernatural.
If you love books about old houses, hidden pasts, and the way history lingers in places and people, this one will pull you in completely.
June 2024: The Unwedding by Ally Condie
A luxury resort in Big Sur, a recent divorcée looking for peace, and a wedding that takes a deadly turn—this one is for thriller lovers.
Ellery planned to spend her anniversary alone, trying to figure out her new life. But when she finds the groom dead in the pool, and a mudslide traps everyone at the resort, it’s clear this is no ordinary getaway.
As more people start dying, the secrets at Broken Point unravel, and Ellery realizes she might not make it out alive.
If you love locked-room mysteries with a sharp, modern twist, this book is like a mix of Agatha Christie and The White Lotus—glamorous, unsettling, and full of secrets waiting to be exposed.
Summer 2024: Twelfth Knight by Alexene Farol Follmuth
A gamer girl with a secret identity, a grumpy football player, and an online romance neither of them sees coming—this book is pure fun.
Vi is tired of people underestimating her, so she creates a tough, anonymous alter ego in her favorite online game.
But when Jack, the school’s laid-back football star, ends up playing alongside her, they connect in ways neither expected. The catch? Jack has no idea who Vi really is.
This is a charming, modern take on mistaken identities, packed with humor, heart, and just the right amount of swoon.
If you love grumpy/sunshine romances and stories about finding where you belong, this one’s a perfect summer read.
May 2024: How to End a Love Story by Yulin Kuang
Helen and Grant have a complicated past—one that neither of them has truly moved on from.
Now, years later, they’re working on the same TV show, forced to face everything they tried to forget. There’s tension, unresolved emotions, and a whole lot of chemistry.
But their history is messy, and Helen’s family still blames Grant for something that happened years ago.
This is a slow-burn, enemies-to-lovers romance with depth and emotional weight.
It’s about grief, love, and figuring out if second chances are worth the risk.
If you love stories that make you feel everything, this one is going to stay with you long after you turn the last page.
April 2024: The Most Fun We Ever Had by Claire Lombardo
Four sisters, each dealing with their own messy lives, and parents whose love story feels impossible to live up to—this book is a deep dive into family, love, and all the complicated emotions that come with both.
Marilyn and David have been madly in love for decades, but their daughters? They’re struggling.
There’s loss, anxiety, big secrets, and a long-lost child suddenly back in the picture, shaking up everything.
If you love multigenerational family dramas like Ask Again, Yes or The Paper Palace, this one is full of rich storytelling, unforgettable characters, and moments that hit right in the heart.
March 2024: Anita De Monte Laughs Last by Xochitl Gonzalez
In 1985, Anita de Monte was a rising star in the art world—until she died under mysterious circumstances. By 1998, hardly anyone remembers her.
But when Raquel, an art history student, stumbles upon Anita’s work, she starts seeing eerie parallels between Anita’s life and her own.
As she digs deeper, Raquel realizes that Anita’s story isn’t just a distant tragedy—it’s a warning.
This book is part mystery, part social commentary, and completely gripping.
If you love books that challenge power structures and spotlight forgotten voices, this one is a must-read.
February 2024: Redwood Court by Delana R.A. Dameron
Growing up in the South in the ’90s, Mika is surrounded by family, love, and the everyday moments that shape a life.
This book captures what it means to come of age in a Black Southern family—the warmth, the struggles, and the unforgettable bonds.
It’s full of nostalgia, heart, and the kind of storytelling that makes you feel like you’re sitting on the front porch, listening to family stories.
If you love books that take you deep into family life with all its ups and downs, this debut is one to add to your list.
January 2024: First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston
A twisty, addictive thriller about deception, identity, and the lengths we go to for survival.
Evie Porter has the perfect life—great boyfriend, beautiful home, and the trust of everyone around her. But there’s one big problem: Evie Porter isn’t real.
Her entire identity is created for her by a mysterious boss known as Mr. Smith. Every mission has the same rules—move in, get close to the target, and complete the job.
But this time, things are different. She’s falling for Ryan, the man she was sent to deceive.
And just when she thinks she might want out, someone from her past—a past she thought was buried—shows up, threatening to ruin everything.
If you love books with strong, complex female leads and shocking twists, this Reese’s Book Club thriller will keep you hooked. It’s smart, suspenseful, and impossible to put down!
These Reese Book Club picks are packed with stories that make you feel, whether it’s love, nostalgia, suspense, or the quiet wonder of nature.
Which one are you most excited about?
