12 Witchy Romance Books You Won’t Regret Reading This Weekend

Romantic Books about witches scaled

I believe the saying is “The best romances are witchy”, and if you say this isn’t correct, idc idc — I have receiptsssssssss a mile long.

This time around, I’m listing 12 witchy romance books that are spellbinding (every single pun intended), so much so they’ll keep you hooked all through.

These books are top of the top, so you’re going to want to get your notebooks out or open your Goodreads or Storygraph apps because you’re about to get swamped with recs!

1. Not The Witch You Wed by April Asher

Not the Witch You Wed

In Not The Witch You Wed, magic-less witch Violet and alpha wolf shifter Lincoln fake-date to comply with Supernatural Laws, only to discover their old feelings are real. 

As they make their way through secrets and threats, the series combines romantic comedy with a touch of magic in the lively setting of New York City.

2. Payback’s A Witch by Lana Harper

Paybacks a witch

Emmy Harlow is a witch returning to her magical town after years who, along with her friends, wants to take revenge on a heartbreaker by using a spellcasting tournament. 

This witch romance story has everything from complicated family histories to romantic entanglements and you’re going to love it!

3. A Letter To Three Witches by Elizabeth Bass

A letter to three witches

A trio of witches land themselves in trouble with the Grand Council due to romantic issues causing magic havoc. 

And the story develops as they band together to challenge the control of their powers.

4. What The Fang by Stacy Kennedy

What the fang

In What The Fang, Willa’s broken magic leads her to Charleston, a city dominated by vampires. 

Saved by the enigmatic Warden Killian, they discover a mystery that intertwines their worlds and this sparks a forbidden romance amid threats that may jeopardize their lives.

5. American Witch by Thea Harrison

American Witch

This romantic witch book revolves around Molly Sullivan, a woman discovering her witch powers while several mysterious events are underway.

Teaming up with Josiah, a powerful witch who wants to take revenge, they slowly unravel a connection between Molly’s husband and Josiah’s nemesis.

6. And They Lived Happily Ever After by Therese Beharrie

And they lived happily ever after

Gaia is a romance author whose dreams come when she shares a surprising kiss with Jacob, a businessman she has had a longtime crush on. 

Their magical connection then challenges them to confront hard truths and break a lasting curse.

7. The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling

The Ex

The Ex Hex takes place nine years after Vivienne Jones curses her ex-boyfriend, Rhys Penhallow. 

But, when Rhys returns to town, several disastrous magical events ensue and this forces Vivi and Rhys to set aside their chemistry and work together to lift the curse threatening Graves Glen.

8. Highland Witch by Kerrigan Bryne

Highland witch

Kenna de Moray is a witch tasked with protecting a Druid relic and when a Viking Berserker enters her life, they must join forces to fight against evil forces. 

Loved every bit of this witch romance book, and trust me when I say you’re going to be floored by the amazing chemistry between these babies. 

9. The Witch Haven by Sasha Peyton Smith

The Witch haven

This beautiful romantic witch book is set in 1911 NYC, where Frances discovers her witch abilities. 

Sent to Haxahaven, a school for witches, she navigates power struggles, a mysterious brother’s death, and a choice between justice and love in a world where magic is both enchanting and perilous.

10. Witch Please by Ann Aguirre

Witch please

Danica is a modern witch with a romantic curse, while Titus is a bakery owner with a tragic past. 

Their irresistible attraction sparks a charming rom-com as they navigate family feuds and decide whether love can break ancient curses.

11. Black Witch Magic by Mila Nicks

Black Witch magic

In this book, Selene Blackstone, a witch cursed for eternity, and sarcastic paranormal investigator Aiden O’Hare, who is determined to uncover the truth about Selene’s family history team up in a town where magic and mystery collide.

12. Small Town Big Magic by Hazel Beck

Small Town Big Magic

Emerson is a bookstore owner who discovers her witch heritage in a small town. 

As she battles her rival, Mayor Skip Simon, and faces an ancient evil, the story combines witchcraft, romance, and the struggle to save a beloved town.

What do you think of these witchy romance novels? Let me know if you’ll watch any of them.

And the related posts have even more book recommendations that’ll keep you hooked. 


Hi! I'm Preye ("pre" as in "prepare" and "ye" as in "Kanye"), and I am a lifelong book lover who enjoys talking about books and sharing bits and pieces of all the fascinating things I come across. I love books so much that I decided to become a developmental editor, and right now, I work with authors to help them tell their stories better. On this blog, I share everything from book recommendations to book reviews and writing tips, so feel free to stop by anytime you like!

View all posts by Preye →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *